The ranking
Edinburgh letting agents, ranked
Where an agency scores well on one platform and poorly on another, both numbers appear. Averaging them would hide the thing you most need to see.
1
1. Clan Gordon
Independent, Leith, founded 2007
4.9★★★★★allAgents, 738 reviews, 97 percent recommend. Google 4.9 from 465.
Clan Gordon is the clearest number one in any city we cover. It scores 4.9 on two independent platforms with a combined base of more than one thousand two hundred reviews, its valuation accuracy score on allAgents is 98 percent, and its registration was confirmed as approved on the Scottish register rather than taken from its own website.
The award record is the longest here too: allAgents gold for best letting agent in Edinburgh in 2023, 2024 and 2025, gold for the EH6 postcode across the same three years, bronze for Scotland in 2024 and 2025, and a gold at the Lettings Agency of the Year awards in 2025. Founded by Andrew and Jonathan Gordon in 2007, the team is now more than twenty people. The one gap is fees, which are not published.
- RegistrationLARN1806018, verified on the Scottish register
- AccreditationARLA Propertymark, RICS, client money protection, Property Redress Scheme, Scottish Property Federation
- FeesNot published
- OfficeSugarbond, 2 Anderson Place, EH6 5NP
- CompanyFounded 2007 by Andrew and Jonathan Gordon
- RecognitionallAgents gold, best letting agent in Edinburgh, 2023, 2024 and 2025
Best for: Landlords who want the strongest evidenced service in the city and do not mind asking for the price.
Visit Clan Gordon
2
2. Umega
Certified B Corporation, about 2,500 homes
4.8★★★★★allAgents, 319 reviews, 96 percent recommend. Google 4.7 from 1,768 per its own site.
Umega publishes its fees, which almost nobody in Edinburgh does, and the numbers are competitive: ten percent plus VAT for management, two hundred and fifty pounds plus VAT to market a tenancy, and ninety five pounds plus VAT for an inventory. That transparency is worth more than half a review point.
It has been a certified B Corporation since 2016, the first private company in Scotland to achieve it, and it holds ARLA and NAEA Propertymark membership with client money protection under certificate C0124869. Around two thousand five hundred homes are managed from offices on Brunswick Street and Ferry Road, plus Dunbar. Note that its own site and a third party mirror disagree on the Google review count, at 1,768 against 1,570.
- RegistrationLARN1804004, verified
- AccreditationARLA and NAEA Propertymark, client money protection C0124869, Property Ombudsman, Investors in People, B Corp
- FeesManagement 10% plus VAT. Marketing 250 pounds plus VAT per tenancy. Inventory 95 pounds plus VAT.
- ScaleAbout 2,500 homes
- CompanyFounded 2005 as Links Property Management, rebranded 2007
- RecognitionScottish Letting Agency of the Year 2018, UK Letting Agency of the Year 2021
Best for: Landlords who want a published price and an agency with a formal ethical commitment behind it.
Visit Umega
3
3. SouthSide Property Management
Independent, Nicolson Street, founded 2009
4.8★★★★★allAgents, 833 reviews, 96 percent recommend. Google 4.5 from 1,447.
SouthSide publishes the most complete fee schedule of any agency in any city on this site, and it is the only tapering one we have found. Full management starts at nine percent plus VAT with a minimum of sixty seven pounds fifty plus VAT, then falls to eight percent after three years, seven percent after five and six percent after seven. A landlord who stays is rewarded for staying, which is rare enough to be worth stating plainly.
The rest of the schedule is published too: six percent plus VAT where a tenant is already in place, twelve percent plus VAT for room lets, let only tiers running from fifteen to forty five percent of the first month, and advertising at one hundred and sixty five pounds plus VAT. The accreditation stack is the broadest in the city and includes ARLA, SAL, SafeAgent, the Chartered Institute of Housing Scotland and Landlord Accreditation Scotland.
- RegistrationLARN1806025, verified
- AccreditationARLA Propertymark, SAL, SafeAgent, Chartered Institute of Housing Scotland, Property Ombudsman, Landlord Accreditation Scotland, NRLA
- FeesFull management from 9% plus VAT, tapering to 6% at seven years. Advertising 165 pounds plus VAT.
- Office20 Nicolson Street, EH8 9DH
- CompanyFounded 2009
- NoteThe only tapering management fee found in any city we cover
Best for: Long term landlords, where the tapering fee makes a real difference over a decade.
Visit SouthSide Property Management
4
4. 1Let
Independent, Manor Place, West End
4.8★★★★★allAgents, 535 reviews, 97 percent recommend
1Let posts the highest fee satisfaction score we found anywhere in Edinburgh, at 97 percent, which is notable given that it does not publish a tariff. Its recommendation rate matches Clan Gordon at 97 percent across a base of 535 reviews.
It sits at four rather than higher for one reason only: there is no comparable Google base to cross check the allAgents figure against, and this site does not rank an agency at the top on a single platform. The accreditation is thorough, covering ARLA, the Property Ombudsman lettings scheme, Landlord Accreditation Scotland, SAL, the Council of Letting Agents and SafeAgent.
- RegistrationLARN1806013, verified
- AccreditationARLA Propertymark, Property Ombudsman, Landlord Accreditation Scotland, SAL, Council of Letting Agents, SafeAgent
- FeesNot published, but fee satisfaction scores 97 percent
- Office20a Manor Place, EH3 7DS
- RecognitionallAgents gold for EH3 in 2024 and 2025, silver in 2023
- NoteOnly one platform carries a meaningful review base
Best for: West End landlords, and anyone who has been burned by an agency whose invoices did not match its quote.
Visit 1Let
5
5. Cullen Property
HMO and student specialist, Rutland Square, founded 1998
4.7★★★★★Google, 356 reviews
Cullen has been letting student and house in multiple occupation property in central Edinburgh since 1998, and roughly seventy percent of its team hold ARLA qualifications, which is a higher proportion than most agencies of its size can claim. It took a British Property Award gold for Edinburgh in 2025 and 2026.
The allAgents sample is small at 3.9 from thirteen reviews, and it is not used as the headline figure here because thirteen reviews cannot outweigh three hundred and fifty six. It is stated so you can see it.
- RegistrationLARN1811026, verified
- AccreditationARLA Propertymark, SAL, Property Ombudsman
- FeesNot published
- Office30 Rutland Square, EH1 2BW
- CompanyFounded 1998
- SpecialismHouses in multiple occupation and student lets
Best for: Student and HMO landlords in the central postcodes.
Visit Cullen Property
6
6. Northwood Edinburgh
Stockbridge since 2003, plus a Leith office
4.7★★★★★allAgents, 46 reviews. Google 4.5 to 4.6 from about 390.
Guaranteed rent is the reason to look at Northwood. The product pays a fixed sum whether the property is let or not, and Northwood has run it longer than almost anyone in the United Kingdom. For a landlord with a mortgage to cover and no appetite for a void, that certainty can be worth more than a percentage point of yield.
Two review bases point the same way, with Google between 4.5 and 4.6 across roughly three hundred and ninety reviews and allAgents at 4.7 from a much smaller 46. It took allAgents gold for EH4 in 2024. No registration number is displayed publicly, which is stated here rather than guessed at.
- RegistrationNot displayed publicly. Ask for it and check the register.
- AccreditationPropertymark, client money protection, Property Ombudsman
- FeesNot published
- OfficesStockbridge since 2003, plus Leith
- OfferGuaranteed rent
- RecognitionallAgents gold for EH4, 2024
Best for: Landlords who want a guaranteed monthly figure rather than the best possible one.
Visit Northwood Edinburgh
7
7. Rettie
RICS regulated, about 2,000 properties across Scotland
4.5★★★★★Google, Edinburgh lettings office, 343 reviews
Rettie is the premium option, with more than twenty lettings staff, around two thousand properties across Scotland, and a genuine specialism in short lets and festival lets that almost nobody else here can match. It won residential letting team of the year at the Scottish Home Awards in 2025.
The allAgents branch figure is 3.2 from just thirteen reviews. That is a small and much less flattering sample than the Google base, and both are shown here. Registration is not displayed on the lettings pages.
- RegistrationNot displayed on the lettings pages
- AccreditationARLA Propertymark, RICS
- FeesNot published
- Office10 Wemyss Place, EH3 6DL
- ScaleAbout 2,000 properties across Scotland, 20 or more lettings staff
- RecognitionResidential letting team of the year, Scottish Home Awards 2025
Best for: Higher value property, and landlords considering festival or short term letting where it is still permitted.
Visit Rettie
8
8. Glenham Property
Independent, Atholl Place, HMO management and refurbishment
4.4★★★★☆Google, 222 reviews
A solid mid sized independent with a clean credential set: ARLA Propertymark membership and client money protection valid to the end of 2026, with registration verified on the Scottish register.
The offer goes beyond letting into buy to let sourcing and refurbishment, which suits a landlord buying a tired flat and wanting one firm to handle the works and then let it. Fees are not published.
- RegistrationLARN1811020, verified
- AccreditationARLA Propertymark, client money protection valid to 31 December 2026
- FeesNot published
- OfficeAtholl Place, EH3 8HP
- SpecialismHouses in multiple occupation, buy to let sourcing, refurbishment
- Review base222 on Google
Best for: Investors buying property that needs work before it can be let.
Visit Glenham Property
9
9. DJ Alexander
Founded 1982, part of the Lomond group
4.2★★★★☆allAgents, Edinburgh lettings branch, 437 reviews, 79 percent recommend
The largest lettings operation in Scotland, with more than ten thousand properties and two hundred staff, run from the John Cotton Centre at Sunnyside. It absorbed the Braemore and Edinburgh Fineholm books in 2022, so a landlord who signed with either of those is now here.
The Edinburgh lettings branch scores 4.2 from 437 on allAgents with a recommendation rate of 79 percent, which is the weakest of the ranked agencies apart from Murray and Currie. That figure is branch specific: the company wide score is different, and the two should not be mixed. No Google aggregate was found for the Edinburgh lettings office.
- RegistrationLARN1812026, company level
- AccreditationClient money protection, Property Redress Scheme, Property Ombudsman and SAL per Citylets
- FeesNot published
- OfficeJohn Cotton Centre, 10 Sunnyside, EH7 5RA
- ScaleMore than 10,000 properties, 200 or more staff
- HistoryAbsorbed Braemore and Edinburgh Fineholm in 2022
Best for: Portfolio landlords who need one agency across several Scottish cities.
Visit DJ Alexander
10
10. Murray & Currie
Queen Street, trading since 2008, Aberdeen office too
3.9★★★★☆allAgents, 142 reviews, 71 percent recommend. Google 3.7 from 302.
Murray and Currie is included on scale and accreditation rather than on satisfaction. It holds both ARLA and NAEA membership and Property Ombudsman redress, it has traded since 2008, and it runs an Aberdeen office alongside the Queen Street base.
Both review platforms agree, and they agree on a weaker picture: 3.9 from 142 on allAgents with 71 percent recommending, and 3.7 from 302 on Google. When two independent bases of that size land in the same place, the number is telling you something. It is ranked tenth for that reason and stated plainly rather than buried.
- RegistrationLARN1904067
- AccreditationARLA and NAEA Propertymark, Property Ombudsman
- FeesNot published
- OfficeQueen Street, EH2, plus an Aberdeen office
- CompanyTrading since 2008
- CautionBoth review platforms show weaker satisfaction than every agency above
Best for: Landlords with property in both Edinburgh and Aberdeen who want one point of contact, subject to checking the reviews yourself.
Visit Murray & Currie